Sunday, September 29, 2013

Chapters 14-15: What happens in this chapter that causes a fight between Jem and Scout? What does this reveal about their relationship? How is this furthered later in the chapter when Dill arrives?


Ever since Jem turned twelve, Scout has noticed that he has developed a “maddening superiority” and a strong sense of wisdom, and this has greatly affected his relationship with Scout. He has been pushing Scout away more than he used to and has been becoming more mature. When Scout was rude to Aunt Alexandra, Jem said, “Try not to antagonize Aunty, hear?  (Lee 183)”. Scout was surprised that Jem would talk to her like he did, and she became so furious with him that after she asked Jem, “You tryin’ to tell me what to do? (Lee 183)”, she started beating him up.  Later, after Atticus broke up the fight, the siblings found Dill under Scout’s bed, and with little hesitation, Jem told Atticus. “Then he rose and broke the remaining code of our childhood, (Lee 187)”, Scout told the readers as Jem called for Atticus. These two scenes prove to us that Scout was correct in her statement in chapter 6 about how she was starting to part ways with Jem. Ever since then, Scout and Jem have been becoming more and more distant as they change and become their own people who do what they believe in as opposed to Scout following Jem’s every order. 

Besides the little things that show that Jem is growing older and becoming more mature, like how he has outgrown his tree house or how he reads all the time, we realize in these chapters that Jem is no longer the adventurer and rule breaker that he used to be. He is more like Atticus in the sense that he advises Scout on how to behave. He even broke his mutual understanding with Scout that they would never tell anyone about their rule-breaking activities when he tells on Dill. He is a more practical and empathetic thinker when he explains that Scout shouldn’t pester Aunt Alexandra because Atticus already has so much to deal with. This way of thinking has developed as Jem has gotten older, and this upsets Scout. That’s why she attacks him… she misses the days when they would always play together. She also feels as though Jem thinks he is more superior than her, so she tries to show him that they are still equal as she fights with him. As Jem has matured, we see that Jem and Scout have become less close and their relationship has changed even more from when Scout first realized it would in chapter 6.

Questions: Why do you think that Jem changed so suddenly after turning twelve? How has he become similar to Atticus? Do you think Scout will eventually be able to see things as Jem does?

2 comments:

  1. While it is true that their is a gap in Jem and Scout's relationship, I think that gap is exaggerated from Scout's point of view. Jem has matured, but not to the point where he can fully exercise his maturity and control over Scout. Atticus notices that they are growing apart and explains to Scout, "Let's leave it at this: you mind Jem whenever he can make you." (Lee 185)
    After finding Dill, Jem broke the unspoken code of their childhood, but I believe he did it for the right reasons. Jem's morals and values in life are becoming more like Atticus', and while some might disagree, I believe this is a good thing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jem and Scout's relationship has changed from the start of the book, but the change is not as big as Scout has told it to be. Jem is getting older and feels as though he should have some more personal space away from his little sister who should be doing, things that girls do. Scout's reaction to Jem's change is appalling as they usually do everything together. Now Jem is trying to tell Scout to start acting like a girl and to do other things away from him. "You tryin' to tell me what to do?" (Lee 183). Jem also feels empowered by the fact that he is older and tells Scout what to do. Though Scout does not like this I believe that Jem is making the right decisions to try and lead his sister in the right direction. Jem is also enjoying reading more than playing outside. I believe that Jem is trying to act like Atticus and it is a good thing. I also think that Scout will soon try to do these things to connect with Jem and Atticus.
    - Irfan

    ReplyDelete